Maggie McFly's | Middlebury Menu (Update 2025)

Pepsi | Diet Pepsi | Mug Root Beer | Mountain Dew | Schweppes Ginger Ale | Starry Lemon Lime | Crush Orange | Tropicana Lemonade

Apple | Orange | Cranberry | Grapefruit | Pineapple

Raspberry | Strawberry

Mango | Peach | Raspberry | Strawberry

Local fresh eggs, apple smoked bacon, spicy mustard aioli

White truffle oil, parmesan cheese, parsley, garlic aioli side

With Sriracha aioli side

Fried buttermilk battered dill pickle chips, house-made ranch side

Fried eggplant, parmesan cheese, house-made marinara sauce

Steamed, topped with black sea salt

With fresh salsa, sour cream and tortilla chips

Edamame, cabbage, corn, carrots, shiitake mushrooms, chives, ginger, garlic ginger soy side

Chicken, Shiitake mushrooms, corn, cabbage, chives, garlic ginger soy and sweet chili sauce sides

Roasted with smoked bacon, garlic aioli garnish

Sesame-glazed black angus beef with a sesame ginger aioli side and rice noodle garnish

Sweet corn, tajin sauce, onions, feta, cilantro, tortilla chips

Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion, croutons, dressing choice

Mixed baby greens, tomato, cucumber, onion, asiago, dressing choice

Romaine lettuce, asiago cheese, croutons, house-made caesar dressing

Open faced with toasted bread and avocado.

Cooked over dry heat.

Tex-Mex, Buffalo Chicken, Steak Philly and Big Mac eggrolls. Served with avocado ranch, bleu cheese, sriracha aioli and thousand island sauces

Steak, peppers, onions and American. Side of Sriracha aioli.

Chicken, bleu cheese, cheddar, buffalo sauce, bleu cheese side

House-made with spicy chicken, corn, black beans, peppers, onions and melted cheese. Served with house-made avocado ranch dipping sauce.

Ground beef, cheddar jack, American, onions, pickles, house-made thousand island sauce side

Battered cauliflower, Buffalo sauce, topped with crumbled bleu cheese. Served with a side of bleu cheese.

Baked and salted with house-made beer cheese and maple dijon sauces

Served with house-made beer cheese and maple dijon bbq side sauces

Fried chicken in buffalo sauce. Served with celery and house-made bleu cheese side.

Shredded buffalo chicken, cheeses, house-fried tortilla and potato chips

Lightly fried coconut battered jumbo shrimp with a house-made pina colada sauce

Tortilla chips, melted cheese, pinto beans, black olives, tomatoes, scallions, served with sour cream and fresh salsa

Spinach, artichoke hearts, mixed cheeses, garlic. Served with vegetable mix, toasted garlic bread, tortilla chips and house-made potato chips

Fried mozzarella, toped with parmesan cheese, house-made marinara sauce side

Melted cheese, bacon, green onions and sour cream.

A grilled tortilla stuffed with cheese, bacon, diced tomatoes and green onions. Served with sour cream and fresh salsa

Panko-crusted fried mac 'n cheese, topped with parmesan over house-made creamy marinara

Calamari in house-made buttermilk batter with a side of house-made marinara and sriracha aioli

Marinated fresh ahi tuna, jalapeos, cilantro, scallions, avocado, sesame seeds, spicy aioli and nori on crispy wontons

Lightly-fried tempura shrimp in sweet chili sriracha with a house-made ranch side sauce

Choose from I Sriracha Honey I Hot I Mild I Honey BBQ I Parmesan Truffle Rosemary Served with house-made bleu cheese and celery side

In a house-made lemon garlic white wine sauce. Served with crostini bread

Topped with crushed peanuts served with sliced carrots, charred chickpea red quinoa and corn salad, oriental noodles, shredded cucumbers, sesame seeds and bibb lettuce leaves with 3 sauces, Asian ginger sauce, orange ginger sauce and house-made peanut sauce.

Fresh mozzarella cheese served over own house-made pesto, with fresh tomatoes, baby arugula and toasted crostini. Drizzled with extra virgin olive oil and balsamic glaze with a sprinkle of freshly ground black pepper.

House-made meatballs. Topped with marinara, warm mozzarella cheese, balsamic glaze drizzle and buttered crostinis

MinI versions of certified Angus beef proprietary blend burgers topped with crispy bacon and American cheese.

A creamy blend of spinach, artichoke hearts, garlic and mixed cheeses. Served with vegetables, toasted garlic bread, tortilla chips and housemade potato chips.

Chicken potstickers, crispy spring rolls, chicken dumplings, BBQ ribs and natural free-range chicken skewers. Served with garlic ginger and housemade Thai peanut sauce.

Fried chicken, pepper jelly and fries.

A large platter of roasted brussels sprouts and served with apple smoked bacon pieces over garlic aioli. Gluten free.

Crispy waffle fries, Black Angus beef short rib, house-made gravy, cheese curds, scallions

Sesame-glazed chicken, romaine, red cabbage, crispy wontons, green onion, shredded carrot, edamame, crispy rice noodles and mandarin oranges with an Asian-ginger dressing

Sesame-glazed chicken skewers, toasted coconut, spicy sweet peppadew peppers, tomato, cucumber, organic mixed baby greens and edamame with a peanut dressing

Fried chicken, bbq sauce, romaine, red onion, cucumber, tomato, charred chickpea quinoa corn salad and candied pecans topped with crispy onion strings and a bbq ranch dressing

Fried buffalo chicken, romaine, celery hearts, cucumber, shredded carrots and tomato with bleu cheese dressing

Sesame-glazed chicken, organic mixed baby greens, romaine, walnuts, apples, mango, tomato and feta with light zinfandel dressing

Wild harvested and line-caught ahi tuna encrusted with sesame seeds, cinnamon, spices, organic mixed baby greens, tomato, avocado, cucumber and peppadew peppers topped with crispy wontons and a creamy balsamic wasabi dressing.

7oz Black Angus sliced NY strip, bibb lettuce hearts, chopped bacon, crumbled bleu cheese, grape tomatoes, red onion, croutons and fresh eggs with a buttermilk ranch dressing

Black Angus beef burger, romaine, cheddar jack, red onion, bacon, diced tomato and pickles, topped with french fries and thousand island dressing

Cilantro and achiote chicken, corn, black beans, spanish rice, lettuce, tomotoes, cheddar jack, enchilada sauce, guacamole and sour cream in a crispy tortilla

Lightly fried sweet & sour orange shrimp, avocado, tomato, cucumber, charred chickpea quinoa salad and romaine, topped with crispy onion strings and maple dijon bbq buttermilk ranch dressing

Orange & herb glaze-coated fresh Faroe Island salmon, organic mixed baby greens, grilled asparagus, snow peas, green beans, peppers and mango with a mango vinaigrette

Skewered sesame-glazed prime steak, grilled shrimp and chicken, organic mixed greens, bleu cheese crumbles, asiago, tomato, red onion and cucumber with a creamy vinaigrette

Romaine topped with house-made croutons, asiago and caesar dressing

Mixed greens, avocado, tomato, cucumber, onion, asiago and dressing of choice

Romaine, tomato, pear, brie, candied pecans, dried cranberries, balsamic vinaigrette

Mixed baby greens, romaine, kalamata olives, grape tomatoes, red onion, fried chickpeas, feta, greek vinaigrette dressing

Romaine, fresh local eggs, bacon, tomato, red onion, cucumbers, mushrooms, avocado, charred chickpea quinoa corn salad, edamame, crumbled bleu cheese, house-made croutonsRomaine, fresh local eggs, bacon, tomato, red onion, cucumbers, mushrooms, avocado, charred chickpea quinoa corn salad, edamame, crumbled bleu cheese with house-made croutons and dressing of choice

Bibb lettuce hearts, chopped bacon, crumbled bleu cheese, house-made croutons, farm fresh eggs, house-made buttermilk ranch dressing. Omit croutons to make gluten-free.

Kale, chicory, red quinoa, julienned broccoli, carrots, grapes, apples, cabbage, sunflower seeds, Brussel sprouts, golden raisins, house-made avocado dressing. Topped with Asiago cheese.

Wild harvested and line caught fresh ahi tuna with sesame seeds, cinnamon and spices served sliced with avocado, tomato and mixed greens, tossed with creamy balsamic wasabi dressing.

On corn tortillas I flour tortillas I bibb lettuceServed with yellow rice and black beans

Lamb, lettuce, tomato, onion, feta on a toasted pita with tzatziki sauce. Served with fries

Chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, feta on a toasted pita with tzatziki sauce. Served with fries

Sliced prime steak, lettuce, tomato, onion, feta on a toasted pita with tzatziki sauce. Served with fries

Panko fried avocado, pico de gallo, chipotle sauce, cilantro, salsa verde and shredded cabbage. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Grilled or blackened shrimp, housemade guacamole, salsa verde, shredded cabbage and pico de gallo. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Crispy white fish, chipotle aioli, shredded cabbage and mango salsa. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Maine lobster meat warmed in butter, chipotle aioli, shredded cabbage, peppadew peppers, cilantro and sesame oil. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Sushi grade, seared rare fresh ahi tuna slices, chipotle aioli, shredded cabbage, pico de gallo. Topped with sesame seeds and wasabi sauce. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Choose any combination of 3 tacos. Served on corn or flour tortillas or bibb lettuce. Served with a side of Spanish rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Baja spiced natural chicken breast, housemade guacamole, salsa verde, peppadew peppers and shredded cabbage. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Choose from lamb, all-natural free-range chicken, sliced prime steak, or plant based chicken. Served on a toasted pita with lettuce, tomato, onion, feta, and tzatziki sauce. Served with fries.

Roasted pulled pork, housemade guacamole, fresh pineapple, cilantro, pico de gallo and shredded cabbage. Topped with salsa verde. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Grilled steak marinated in Korean barbecue sauce with salsa verde, peppadew peppers, shredded jack cheese, housemade guacamole and shredded cabbage. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Braised short ribs, guacamole, shredded cabbage, roasted pineapple and cilantro. Topped with pico de gallo and salsa verde. Served with a side of rice and charred chickpea red quinoa corn salad.

Black angus burgers, crispy bacon, tomato, American cheese, bibb lettuce on potato buns

Fried chicken, bleu cheese dressing, buffalo sauce on potato buns. Served with fries

House-made meatballs, marinara, mozzarella on potato buns. Served with fries.

Smoked pulled pork, bbq sauce, cheddar, house-made coleslaw on potato buns. Served with fries

Grass fed beef, Gouda cheese, maple smoked bacon, bibb lettuce, tomato, red onion and pickles on a potato bun. Served with fries

Tomato, red onion, pickles, bibb lettuce on a potato bun

Applewood smoked bacon, sriracha aioli, crumbled blue cheese, tomato, pickles, red, onion and fried jalapeos on a potato bun. Served with fries

Asian slaw, pickled onion, korean BBQ sauce, gochujang aioli, sesame seed potato bun

Bacon, blue cheese, herb aoili, bibb lettuce, tomato, pickles and red onion on a potato bun. Served with fries

Bacon, cheddar, bibb lettuce, tomato, pickles, red onion and yellow mustard on a soft pretzel bun.

Applewood smoked bacon, American, sauted mushroom, burgundy caramelized onions, signature sauce, bibb lettuce, tomato, pickles and red onion on a potato bun. Served with fries

Bacon, mac 'n cheese, bibb lettuce, tomato, pickles, red onion, sriracha aioli on a pretzel bun. Served with fries

Fried pickles, cheddar, tomato, shredded lettuce, signature thousand island, sesame seed potato bun

Applewood smoked bacon, American, bibb lettuce, red onion, tomato, pickles on a potato bun. Served with fries

Bacon, cheddar, BBQ sauce, onion ring, bibb lettuce, red onion, tomato and pickles on a potato bun. Served with fries.

All- Natural Antibiotic-Free Turkey Burger, Bibb Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles, Red Onion, Potato Bun

House-made with I mayo, cilantro, bread crumbs, corn, mushrooms, peppadew peppers. Topped with I Cheddar-jack, avocado, tomato, sriracha aioli on a potato bun. Served with fries.

Bacon, fresh fried egg, cheddar, bibb lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, sriracha aioli on a potato bun. Served with fries

All-natural antibiotic-free turkey burger, applewood smoked bacon, Swiss, avocado, tomato, bibb lettuce and herb aioli on a sourdough roll. Served with fries

Wagyu beef burger, gouda cheese, burgundy caramelized-onions, garlic aioli on a potato bun. Served with fries

Plant-based beef, vegan cheese, onion, tomato, pickles, lettuce, signature vegan sauce on a pretzel bun. Served with fries

Classic burger with Maggie's signature BBQ pulled pork, coleslaw and cheddar cheese, on soft pretzel bun. Made with Angus beef chuck, brisket and short rib.

Lager battered chicken, fries, with maple dijon bbq sauce

Fried chicken, waffles, topped with maple bacon gravy

Fried chicken, sweet and sour orange sauce, sesame seeds, basmati rice, julienned vegetables

Panko parmesan crust chicken, asiago mashed potatoes, creamy lemon sauce, asparagus garnish

Sauted chicken, marsala wine sauce, mushrooms, fettuccine, topped with asiago

Romano and asiago crusted chicken, fettuccine, creamy marinara sauce. Topped with asiago

Parmesan panko breaded chicken, marinara, mozzarella, fettuccine. Topped with asiago

Sauted chicken, creamy lemon sauce, mushrooms, capers, fettuccine. Topped with asiago.

Sauted chicken, mushrooms, madeira sauce, mozzarella, asiago mashed potatoes, asparagus garnish

Breaded chicken, pesto-lemon cream sauce, fettuccine. Topped with arugula, tomato and parmesan

Breaded chicken, spicy New Orleans sauce, peppers, onions, cheese tortellini. Topped with asiago

All-natural free-range chicken breast topped with fresh Luizzi mozzarella, tomato, basil pesto and balsamic glaze. Served with basmati rice. Gluten-free.

Sauteed all-natural free-range chicken breast topped with fresh asparagus, fresh shiitake mushrooms and melted mozzarella cheese. Covered with housemade Madeira wine sauce. Served garlic mashed potatoes.

Fresh cod fried in beer batter, served with fries, house-made coleslaw and tartar sauce

Lightly fried coconut battered jumbo shrimp, vegetable medley, asiago mashed potatoes with pina colada sauce

Shrimp, house-made creamy asparagus, applewood smoked bacon, corn and pepper risotto, parmesan, asiago, garlic wine sauce

Shrimp, Prince Edward Island fresh mussels, calamari, clams, peppers, onions, cilantro, yellow rice in a spicy tomato seafood broth

Fresh Faroe Island salmon, shredded coconut, basmati rice, julienned vegetables and pina colada sauce.

Orange-glazed Faroe Island salmon, thyme, mustard, tarragon, basil, parsley, creamy lemon sauce with asiago mashed potatoes and asparagus garnish

Wild-harvested line-caught fresh ahi tuna encrusted with sesame seeds, cinnamon and spices, garlic ginger sauce, basmati quinoa rice, brussels sprouts with applewood smoked bacon with garlic aioli

Shrimp, lobster, scallops, panko breading, garlic in a sherry wine lobster cream sauce

Topped with herb butter and served with basmati red quinoa rice and Brussels sprouts with apple smoked bacon.

Topped with herb butter and served with basmati red quinoa rice and Brussels sprouts with apple smoked bacon.

Jumbo shrimp stuffed with crabmeat and herb stuffing. Topped with a house-made creamy lemon sauce and served with whole grain brown rice and sauteed spinach.

Fresh sea scallop, creamy roasted cauliflower with maple bacon truffle cream sauce, balsamic reduction and sauteed broccolini.

Jumbo shrimp sauteed in garlic, white wine, olive oil, fresh basil, parsley, diced tomato and lemon. Served over angel hair pasta.

Vanilla chocolate chip cake, vanilla buttercream filling, rolled in chocolate chips, scratch-made cookie topperCreated locally by HC Sweet, Watertown | CT

Funfetti cake, vanilla mousse filled, vanilla buttercream, rainbow sprinkles, strawberry wafer topperCreated locally by Hardcore Sweet, Watertown | CT

Chocolate cake and mousse, peanut butter buttercream, brownie, peanut butter chipsCreated locally by HC Sweet, Watertown | CT

Red velvet cake, white chocolate, buttercream rolled in sanding sugar, cheesecake filling, cheesecake bites toppedCreated locally by Hardcore Sweet, Watertown | CT

Vegan chocolate cake, eggless cookie dough filling and frosting, rolled in chocolate chipsCreated locally by Hardcore Sweet, Watertown | CT

Graham cracker crust, classic cheesecake fillingCreated locally by Hardcore Sweet, Watertown | CT

Cinnamon biscoff crusted, cookie-butter cheesecake filling, cinnamon mousse and crumle topping, icing glazeCreated locally by Hardcore Sweet, Watertown | CT

Chocolate Oreo crust, chocolate cheesecake and ganache filling, dark chocolate curls, white chocolate drizzled Oreo, chocolate mousse toppingCreated locally by Hardcore Sweet, Watertown | CT

Vanilla and chocolate ice cream, confetti sprinkle, chocolate crumble with whipped cream

Vanilla ice cream, Oreo crumble, chocolate chips, whipped cream and chocolate sauce topping

Fudge brownie, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, walnuts and chocolate sauce

Chocolate or vanilla

Fresh apples, crispy spiced oat crust, whipped cream with vanilla ice cream

Warm chocolate cake with liquid chocolate center and vanilla ice cream. Topped with whipped cream.

Chocolate pudding, Oreo crumble, whipped cream and gummy bears

Vanilla and chocolate ice cream, warm lava cakes, walnuts, whipped cream, gummy worms, chocolate | strawberry | caramel sauces

Chocolate cake, chocolate filling and chocolate chips

Carrot cake, cream cheese icing, pecans

Mascarpone cream, coffee-brandy soaked lady fingers and imported sweet cocoa.

Mug fountain root beer and vanilla ice cream

Flavor selection blended with ice cream

Red velvet cake cream cheese icing, white chocolate shavings.

Gluten-free.

Vegan chocolate cake, vegan oreo buttercream, rolled in crushed oreos.

Chocolate cake espresso (fair trade organic) buttercream caramel drizzle, sea salt and chocolate covered espresso bean.

Yellow cake, Vanilla Buttercream, Rainbow Sprinkles

Chocolate cake with chocolate ganache filling, chocolate buttercream, chocolate shavings

Chocolate cake peanut butter mousse filling, peanut butter buttercream, dipped in chocolate ganache, topped with crushed reese's cups

Gluten free. Gluten free chocolate cake, vanilla buttercream, mini chocolate chips. Topped with gluten-free chocolate chip cookie

Cracker jack caramel-coated popcorn and peanuts, vanilla ice cream, topped with whipped cream and caramel.

Build your own s'mores to toast over your own table campfire. Marshmallows, graham crackers and chocolate.